They say that history is written by the victors. Thus, the story of the American Revolution is largely one of heroic figures such as George Washington and Patrick Henry and largely-than-life episodes, such as the winter at Valley Forge or victory at Yorktown. Because America won its independence from Great Britain, rather than lost the war and reverted to some form of colonial status, the whole story seems ordained, as if it were written in the stars.
Little thought is given to how different America would be had the war turned out differently, and even less to the losers in the struggle; not the British regulars, but rather the thousands of ordinary colonists who remained loyal to the British Crown. The loyalist version of events is almost never encountered.
Which brings us to the story of two Carolina loyalists named John Dunn and Benjamin Booth. Booth and Dunn were lawyers from Salisbury, North Carolina, a modest and poor town in the remote backcountry. The two would have been entirely forgotten, but for their petitions alleging mistreatment by their Whig neighbors, who arrested and deported them from the region in the summer of 1775. In the stories of Booth and Dunn we hear the rare testimony of history’s losers.
Dunn’s troubles began in the late spring of 1775. By his own account, he was minding his own business when “a Certain William Temple Coles” approached him. Coles read out loud pro-British resolves “declaring their disapprobation to the Measures then Carrying on by the people at Boston.”
The two men approved of these “Very Much” and decided to draw up similar loyalist resolves for their county. Later Coles produced “a paper Containing a Declaration of Allegiance, fidelity and obedience to his Majesty and Submission to the British Acts of Parliament.”
This was going to be a problem for them, because Rowan County, where they lived, was a hotbed of Whig sentiment. The area had been settled by Scotch-Irish Presbyterians who were anti-English from religion, conviction and historical memory. In fact, after the war Lt. Col. Banastre Tarleton called the area “more hostile to England than any other in America.”
Moreover, Dunn was a bit of a drinker and prone to shoot his mouth off in front of his neighbors. One night, at a tavern he began “arguing warmly in favor of Ministerial measures” against America. No doubt the bar went quiet as in some Western movie before someone gets beaten up. Someone present took notes of what Dunn was saying and reported them to the local Whig leaders. Dunn, it was reported, had stated that the Americans “had no right to prescribe to the Prince and Parliament!” As perhaps the last straw, Dunn had a pet dog named Tory.
As relations deteriorated with England that summer, local leaders took action to have Dunn arrested. His friend Booth it appears was arrested for being friends with Dunn, and a known British sympathizer. According to Dunn he was “just recovering out of a fit of Sickness and at my own house in Salisbury … [when] a number of Armed persons Entered … [and] Seized upon my person.” He was taken away under guard. A few minutes later he “saw Mr. Booth Conducted in the same manner.”
They were to be interrogated, they were told, in “Order to Examine us with regard to our Political Sentiments, with regard to the American Cause of liberty.”
That same night, they were taken under guard to nearby Charlotte. The next day, they were tried and sentenced for anti-Revolutionary fervor. Their sentence was expulsion from the community. The two were sent away to Camden, South Carolina, and thence to Charleston where they would be held for over a year. As Dunn caustically put it, their trial and sentence was in “Direct Violation of those Rights and Privileges which Americans contend with Great Britain for at this Time.”
That may have been true, but there was no going home for either one of them. Anger and violence in the remote Southern backcountry would only increase over the next several years. They two men could consider themselves lucky to have gotten out alive in the summer of 1775. No doubt a few years later, the story would have had a grimmer ending.
 The account of the arrest of Booth and Dunn is taken largely from Volume 10 of the State and Colonial Records of North Carolina, “Memorandum from John Ross Dunn concerning his imprisonment,” July 27, 1776, pages 673-678.